pitchingproductionbusiness

Pitching a Podcast to a Production Company: What Banijay, All3 or Goalhanger Are Likely Looking For

ppodcasting

2026-02-04

9 min read

Insider checklist and pitch template for production houses—what Banijay, All3 and Goalhanger want in 2026: KPIs, formats, and deal tactics.

Pitching a Podcast to a Production Company in 2026: A Practical Insider’s Checklist

Hook: You’ve built an audience, but production houses now want shows that scale, monetize directly and add IP value. With consolidation accelerating—think Banijay + All3 talks—and subscription-first models like Goalhanger’s, production companies aren’t buying podcasts the way they did in 2019. This guide gives the exact checklist, KPIs and pitch deck template buyers such as Banijay, All3 or Goalhanger are likely scanning for in 2026.

Why the bar has risen in 2026

Two industry currents define the buyer mindset this year: consolidation and diversification of revenue. Large producers are consolidating content libraries to aggregate audiences and control IP; at the same time, buyers prize shows that already drive direct revenue (subscriptions, events, merch) or have clear premium upsell potential. Recent headlines show both forces in play: high-profile merger discussions among indie TV studios and publisher-producers, and podcast companies like Goalhanger reporting >250,000 paying subscribers and ~£15m annual subscriber income across networks. Production houses expect podcast assets to be investments—scalable, monetizable, and rights-cleansed.

Top-level ask: What production companies want first (inverted pyramid)

Proven audience and growth momentum — not just raw downloads but retention, subscriber conversion and demographic fit.
Monetization pathways — existing revenue (ads + direct pay), ARPU, and low-hanging opportunities (paywall, live, licensing).
IP and adaptability — story-led formats that convert to TV, books, live or short-form video.
Host & talent considerations — exclusivity, availability, marketability and social reach.
Operational hygiene — clean rights, documented production costs, and a reproducible workflow.

Practical KPI thresholds that make shows attractive in 2026

Production buyers don’t expect every show to hit blockbuster numbers, but they do look for performance signals that predict scale and monetization. Use these as target thresholds when placing metrics in your pitch deck.

Active Audience: 30k+ monthly active listeners (or 50k+ downloads per month) is a common threshold for regional producers; 100k+ for national/international targeting.
Subscriber Conversion: 1.5%–5% conversion from engaged listeners to paid subscribers is excellent. Goalhanger’s network averages underline the strategic value of a mid-single-digit conversion when multiplied across shows.
ARPU (Annual): £40–£80 per paying subscriber is market-validated in the U.K./EU—higher for premium communities and value bundles.
Retention / Completion Rate: 60%+ episode completion for long-form and 70%+ for 20–30 minute formats signal sticky content.
Churn: Monthly churn < 5% is attractive; < 3% is premium.
Engagement: Newsletter open rates 25%+, social engagement (likes/RTs) >1% of follower base, and community activity (Discord/Slack) with 10%+ active month-to-month.
Revenue Mix: Buyers prefer diversified revenue: ads (40–60% of revenue), subscriptions (20–40%), live/ticketing and merch (10–20%).

What formats production companies are prioritizing in 2026

Buyers are optimizing their slates towards formats that lower risk and increase cross-platform upside. Position your show according to these format priorities:

Host-led evergreen interview series: Scales across seasons, strong for sponsorships and conversions to live events.
Serialized narrative/documentary: High value for adaptation & licensing; attracts longer listening sessions and premium subscribers.
Short-form explainers (8–15 mins): Built for social, high completion; good pipeline for video shorts monetization and discovery.
Sports & fandom communities: Proven subscription unit economics (see Goalhanger); great for membership, ticketing and brand partnerships.
Hybrid show+event models: Episodes designed to feed live shows, giving instant revenue uplifts and stronger sponsor deals.

Buyer psychology: What Banijay, All3 and Goalhanger specifically value

Banijay / All3-style buyers (scale + IP consolidation): They look for formats with international adaptation potential, clear licensing paths and low-friction production scale. Your pitch should highlight format elements that travel (non-language dependent mechanics, local franchiseability) and any existing territorial interest.

Goalhanger-style buyers (subscription-first, community monetizers): They prioritise direct-pay economics, audience stickiness, and host brands that can be turned into memberships, live tours and exclusive content. If you can show path-to-subscribe behavior (early access, bonus episodes uptake), you’re in a sweet spot.

“Consolidation is driving producers to buy audience and IP that immediately monetize or can be scaled internationally.” — industry summary, 2026 headlines

Insider checklist before you pitch (data room & prep)

Think like a buyer. Have this ready before you request a meeting.

Executive Summary (1 page): Concept, host(s), audience snapshot, revenue today and ask (license, stake, distribution deal).
Audience Pack: 12-month downloads by episode, MAU/MAU trends, listener geography, platform breakdown, listener cohorts, top-performing episodes.
Monetization Report: Ad revenue (CPM by format), subscription revenue, ARPU, churn, top sponsors, sample sponsor briefs/case studies.
Rights & Contracts: Host agreements, music/clearing status, third-party contributor releases—list exceptions and solutions.
Production & Cost Model: Per-episode cost, cash-flow, team roles, time-to-produce, and scalable elements (can you produce 3x episodes without linear cost increases?).
Growth Plan: 12–24 month plan with milestones, spend allocation, and collaboration asks (e.g., distribution marketing, sync licensing support).
IP Mapping: Existing IP (books, archives), rights you own, and possible adaptations (TV, format licensing, merchandising).
Case Studies: Sponsor case study, successful subscriber campaign, or a successful live event—numbers matter.

Slide-by-slide pitch deck template for production houses

Keep decks tight: 10–12 slides. Make each slide defensible with data on a backup page.

Cover: Show title, tagline, host headshot(s), contact.
One-line thesis: Why this show fits their slate (scale/monetize/IP).
Audience snapshot: MAU, downloads/mo, top demos & geos.
Engagement & retention: Completion, session length, cohort retention.
Revenue today: Ads, subs, events, merchandising—include ARPU & LTV headline.
Growth traction: 12-month trends, lift from promo or partnerships.
Format & IP potential: Why it scales & adapts; list adaptation ideas.
Host & talent: Availability, exclusivity wish, social reach, prior credits.
Commercial opportunities: Sponsor packages, membership tiers, live/merch/ticketing.
Financial ask & structure: What you want (acquisition, co-pro, distribution deal) and proposed economics.
3–5 slides of backup data: Downloads by episode, sponsor results, legal/rights summary.

Pitch language: One-page narrative to open conversations

Use this lean email or summary to secure the initial meeting. Replace bracketed text with your data.

Subject: [Show name] — [Format] with [X] MAU & clear subscription upside

Body:

Hi [Name],

[Show name] is a [format] hosted by [host name], reaching [X] monthly listeners with [Y]% episode completion and [Z] paying subscribers (ARPU £[A]). We’ve proven sponsor lift (sample: [brand] campaign drove [metric]) and generated £[B] from live/tickets in the last 12 months.

We’re seeking a partner to scale distribution, accelerate subscriber growth and explore IP adaptations. Our draft ask: [acquisition stake / co-production / distribution]. I’ve attached a 10-slide deck and audience pack—happy to meet for 20 minutes next week.

Best,

[Your name & contact]

Negotiation points production companies will push (and how to prepare)

Ownership vs revenue share: Buyers may ask for IP ownership for TV/format rights. If you want to keep audio IP, propose a split: audio stays with creator, visual/format rights licensed exclusively for X years.
Exclusivity: Expect requests for platform or talent exclusivity. Push for time-limited exclusives (12–24 months) or category-based carve-outs.
Performance earn-outs: Suggest milestones (subscriber count, revenue thresholds) that unlock further payments or equity.
Data & access: Buyers will want analytics access. Agree on a clean data room and an audit clause rather than open-ended access.

Advanced strategies that increase your deal value

Don’t just present what you have—show the levers.

Structured subscription funnel: Show a tested onboarding flow (trial, welcome series, premium content) and conversion metrics.
Cross-platform content plan: Engineered short videos, newsletters and clips that reduce CAC and increase discovery.
Localized format plan: For conglomerates like Banijay/All3, outline quick-win localization scripts and partner-market hooks.
Sponsor case study kit: Pre-made creative concepts and performance projections for top potential partners.
Event scope: An annual roadmap for live shows and monetized community experiences (VIP tiers, ticketed streams).

Real-world mini case: Why Goalhanger’s model excites buyers

Goalhanger’s public numbers in 2026 show the power of subscription-first, host-driven networks. With >250k paying subscribers and an average subscriber spend near £60/year, their model converts a strong host brand into predictable, high-margin recurring revenue. For production companies, that recurring stream de-risks acquisition: revenue is not reliant solely on volatile CPM markets, and member data enables targeted monetization. If your show already has membership or a strong funnel, highlight it—the multiple applied to recurring revenue can be the dominant valuation driver.

Common mistakes that sink pitches

Giving headline downloads without cohort or retention context.
Not clarifying rights—uncleared music or missing guest releases create legal roadblocks.
Overstating sponsor interest without signed proof or confirmed terms.
Absent cost model—buyers need to know burn per episode and scale unit economics.

After the meeting: Data you should send within 48 hours

Updated 1-page executive summary
10-slide deck (PDF) and the audience pack (CSV or dashboard exports)
Sample sponsor brief and creative example
Rights checklist & key contracts (redacted if needed)

Checklist recap: What to put at the top of your inbox before you pitch

Audience evidence—trends and cohorts, not just top-line downloads
Monetization proof—ads, subs, events with numbers
Production costs and scalability
IP & rights clarity
Clear ask—what you want and proposed commercial structure

Final tactical tips for 2026

Lead with outcomes: show how your listeners convert to money or TV-friendly IP in 1–2 slides.
Quantify subscriber economics—buyers love predictable revenue.
Showcase short-form video playbooks—discoverability budgets flow to audio-plus-video strategies.
Pitch formats that are franchiseable—producers are buying scale as much as content.

Conclusion & call-to-action

Production companies consolidating content in 2026 are hunting for low-risk, high-upside podcast assets: proven audiences, diversified monetization, adaptable formats and clean legal packaging. Present your show as a business—document the economics, remove legal friction, and pitch the format’s cross-platform future. Use the checklist and deck above to convert ambition into offers.

Ready to tighten your pitch? Send your one-page executive summary and top 3 KPIs to our review desk for a tailored critique—optimized for buyers like Banijay, All3 and Goalhanger. Fast feedback, industry-standard redlines, and a sample slide you can drop straight into your deck.

podcasting

Contributor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.